Treatment Of Stocks Raises Eyebrows
Auto Profit Margins Expected To Rise In 2013
While Peugeot-Citroen, Fiat, Opel-Vauxhall and Ford Europe drown in red ink, Renault, alone among Europe’s mass car manufacturers, kept comfortably in the black in 2012.
Investors also agree that the future looks promising for Renault, although some worry that the company’s treatment of stocks is a cause for concern.
Renault’s so-called operating margin fell to €729 million in 2012, from €1.09 billion a year earlier, which equates to a margin of 1.8 per cent. But to be fair to its competitors, Renault’s core auto division actually showed a small, €25 million net loss.
Deutsche described Renault’s performance as reassuring, even if the quality was poor.
“This gives us confidence that operating margin recovery should be strong in the coming years thanks to strong growth of international operations and to a recovery in Europe linked to its product offensive and cost reduction programme at French plants,” said Deutsche Bank’s Gaetan Toulemonde.
“In 2013, we expect the group to generate an operating margin of €1.2 billion, a €500 million improvement on 2012,” Toulemonde said.
Credit Suisse analyst Erich Hauser worried that Renault’s treatment of stocks, where it managed to increase the level of inventories at independent dealers to record highs, while limiting captive dealers to record lows.
“Renault still sees no increased risk coming from such a commercial strategy,” Hauser said.
“We remain unconvinced that companies can continue to generate all their cash by pushing new cars into dealerships and off their own balance sheet,” Hauser said.
Commerzbank analyst Sascha Gommel is an optimist for Renault.
“Renault’s outlook is encouraging as it expects to grow unit sales this year, and expects positive earnings and free cash flow in the automotive division. This impressively demonstrates Renault’s relative outperformance against direct peers Peugeot and to a lesser degree Fiat,” Gommel said.
Russia
Citi Research analyst Philip Watkins points to Renault’s position in Russia as a potential source of success, with the possibility of consolidating sales from Avtovaz. This could represent sales of 800,000 by 2015, or 24 per cent of global penetration. Also the new model programme is promising, with the new Twingo shared with Daimler in 2014, a new platform for the Espace which will be shared with Nissan and the Renault Laguna, and a new Megane in 2015/2016.
Neil Winton – March 3, 2013

No comments yet.