Long-Distance Charging Problems Will Boost Plug-In Hybrids.
“Most drivers leaving for a long-distance weekend or holiday trip run
the risk of their trips taking double or triple the time for a diesel or
gasoline internal combustion engine vehicle.”
One of the unintended consequences of the electric car revolution will be a painful doubling or tripling in long-distance journey times as the charging structure is overwhelmed, according to consultancy Frost & Sullivan.
This will also mean that there is a great future for plug-in hybrid gasoline electric vehicles because of their greater flexibility and ability to switch to traditional internal combustion engine (ICE) power for long trips, Paris, France-based Frost & Sullivan analyst Nicolas Meilhan said.
Plug-in hybrids don’t need a hugely expensive fast-charging network. They typically have a battery-only range of around 30 miles, and normal ICE range. Meilhan said battery-only vehicles are more suited to short-range city use.
That won’t please Tesla Inc CEO Elon Musk who famously has little time for hybrids. Asked why he didn’t add a range-extender to the Model S turning it into a hybrid, he said this some years ago.
“That would be like a frog, able to function in and out of the water, but not very good at either,” Musk said.
As forecasters scramble to raise their estimates for the number of battery-only vehicles on the roads, the implications of an inadequate charging system loom large.
Updated projections
Morgan Stanley recently updated its projections for battery electric vehicle sales. The investment bank said its so-called “bull” case for electric cars reaches almost 70 per cent of global sales by 2050. Its least optimistic forecast still hits 47 per cent by 2050, 7 per cent by 2030, and 24 per cent by 2040. Either way, that adds up to a lot of electric cars queuing for a charge on the highway if the network can’t get close to matching ICE-type efficiency.
Frost & Sullivan’s Meilhan paints a bleak picture.
“Most drivers leaving for a long-distance weekend or holiday trip run
the risk of their trips taking double or triple the time for a diesel or
gasoline internal combustion engine vehicle. A battery electric car with
“fast” electric charge (50 kW) is approximately 25 times slower to fill
than a vehicle with conventional fuel. Gasoline or diesel drivers will take
5 minutes to take on board what it will take 2 hours for a battery electric
car as they will get 6 times less energy in 20 minutes – the equivalent of
100 kilometers compared with 600 kilometers (65 miles versus 375 miles),” Meilhan said.
Meilhan also said the likelihood of too few very expensive charging
units compared with ubiquitous conventional ones will lead to huge queues and frustrating delays. This will be a powerful incentive to buy a plug-in for long distance journeys.
Battery electric vehicles are more suited for city and urban driving. These will be small and light specially designed cars, he said.
40 minutes to fill
Ultra-fast charging (150 kW) deployment is expected on
European highways in the coming years but it will still take 40 minutes to fill an electric car with the range that you get in 5 minutes with your
conventional fuel car, Meilhan said.
Simon Lonsdale, Vice President, Business Development, ChargePoint Inc, said in a recent interview he doesn’t think this will be a problem.
“ChargePoint, now having data from nearly 25 million charging sessions, envisions that charging needs will divide into two categories – around 80 per cent of charging will take place in home and work, while another 20 per cent will be at public sites like parking lots, street-side or fast charging stations,” Lonsdale said.
ChargePoint, which says it is the world’s largest electric vehicle charging network, recently said it sold more than 200 rapid charge systems to Britain’s InstaVolt as the first stage of its ambitious European expansion plans.
“Fast charging is for the rare occasions when drivers travel longer distances. Charging for the overwhelming majority of the time will be where drivers are, at home, work, or around time as they are doing something else,” he said.
Frost & Sullivan’s Meilhan said another negative for electric cars is the fact that with high-speed highway driving, range drops by 50 to 60 per cent from the level achieved in slower, urban use.

No comments yet.