index page Wintons Opinion cars index page Global Warming stories page under construction

First reviews, more pictures of the latest, hottest cars
Range Rover Diesel V8
Range Rover Diesel V8
Yes You Can Have It All
Range Rover Diesel V8
Range Rover Diesel V8
Range Rover Diesel V8
Range Rover Diesel V8
Range Rover Diesel V8
Range Rover Diesel V8

V8 Diesel Gives Quiet, Silky Perambulation, Or Pounding Performance
In The Unlikely Event You Should Want To, It Goes Anywhere Too
 “to avoid a ghastly, destructive and expensive mistake at the refuelling pump there’s a device which will reject petrol”

BARCELONA, Spain Love him or loathe him, it is impossible to avoid Jeremy Clarkson’s opinion on cars, or just about anything under the sun. If he’s not grinning at you from BBC TV’s Top Gear, he’ll be opining in various national newspapers. If you seek refuge in cable TV, you can’t avoid endless reruns of clapped out Top Gear programmes and long-demised chat shows. Leaving the country won’t help. I once turned on the TV in Scottsdale, Arizona, and there’s was the ubiquitous Clarkson, in my face, insisting on being heard.

Personally, you can count me in the plus column when it comes to the man’s journalism. He’s a witty writer, and his BBC TV programme on a shared hero, Isambard Kingdom Brunel, was fabulous. But I’m a loather when it comes to his political opinions, even though I share many of his views on politicised issues like global warming and mad environMENTALists, as he calls them.

What sticks in my craw is Clarkson’s infantile, cheap, ignorant, grand-standing views on America, which he regularly insults from a know-nothing position. Sadly, his clichéd view of American and Americans is common among British journalists who cover the Great Satan.

During my seven years as a journalist for Reuters in New York, there was always a coterie of British reporters for the national newspapers who only ever met other British journalists and their families. They met in the same bar most days, watched the same TV news programmes, and relied on each other to build on the prejudices that they’d been primed with before setting off across the Atlantic.

Nothing further from the truth
That’s why we get this ludicrous view of Americans in our mainstream media as overweight, overpaid and overwrought. Americans are always portrayed as selfish bullies. American politics is always just about money.  The Iraqi war is all about oil. Nothing could be further from the truth. But I digress.

The main area that I find myself in disagreement with Clarkson though is his views on cars. I loathe all the cars he loves. A recent column in the Sunday Times, in which he lambasted the Range Rover Sport, coincided with my return from a trip driving the new Range Rover V8 diesel. I had been mightily impressed with Range Rovers in general and this new engine in particular, and seeing the headline “I’m sorry this is absolutely gross” grabbed my attention. A sentence in the story also leapt from the page.

“I simply cannot remember driving any car that provoked so much mirth from other road users. All the way round the M25 people were slowing down for a better look and all gave the same verdict. A resounding, open-mouthed thumbs down,” said Clarkson.

My first thought was that the derision (which came before the terrible accident to his pet hamster) was probably aimed at Clarkson rather than the car. But that doesn’t seem to have entered the great man’s head. Secondly, it is unlikely that he would have driven all the way around the M25.  

In fact, it didn’t become apparent until about half way through the article that Clarkson was actually talking about an Overfinch Range Rover Sport, a special bespoke version which costs about £30,000 more than the regular one, and which is certainly an embarrassing, look-at-me, I’ve got loadsamoney, chav dream car.

Restrained, sophisticated, responsible
The Range Rover V8 diesel which I was driving on the highways and off-road tracks around Barcelona was much more restrained, sophisticated and responsible. The new diesel – there’s also a V6 diesel in the range – is more powerful and smooth than the old straight six-diesel, cutting about 4 seconds from the 0-60 mph time, but matching the fuel economy of 25.1 mpg.

The new diesel will allow Range Rover to compete with much more authority in important markets like Germany, where Mercedes and Audi/VW already have big capacity oil-burners. You could say that without a diesel, big SUVs like the Range Rover were doomed to die because of the pressure from politicians to insist on more frugal use of scarce resources. Unfortunately, Range Rover seems a bit behind the curve in diesel technology compared with the Germans, particularly when you think about the VW V10 diesel, or the new Audi V12 TDI which will be launched at the Paris Car Show in October. This V12 is a direct descendent of the Le Mans winning race car.

Range Rover has added more standard equipment, making the Terrain Response system standard across the range, and an electronic parking brake. It has improved the cabin with extra stowage, enhanced finishes, better air conditioning, and added the option of cooled front seats.

The V8 diesel is eerily quiet, and to avoid the possibility of a ghastly, destructive and expensive mistake at the refuelling pump, Land Rover has developed a new, patented device which will reject any attempts at filling the tank with petrol.

6-speed automatic
The new engine is matched to a 6-speed automatic transmission, with the suspension set-up similar to the Range Rover Supercharged to improve handling and ride comfort.

It provided superlative punch when required, and effortless, quiet cruising on the highways. The Dynamic Response technology reduces roll and improves handling, although not surprisingly, this big, high SUV does feel a bit disconcerting on fast corners compared with regular saloons.

Off-road, the Range Rover was as tenacious and sure-footed as you’d expect. The standard Terrain Response system allows the driver to choose one of five settings using a pop-up rotary control on the centre console when venturing off road. If you can’t figure out the hieroglyphics, there’s a set of prompts on the sat-nav screen to help you out.

The settings – general driving, grass/gravel/snow, mud and ruts, sand, and rock crawl – adjust things like ride height, engine torque, hill descent control, electronic traction control and transmission settings. In short, most of the skills involved in traversing alien off- road conditions are taken care of by the computer. The Range Rover handled all this with aplomb. In the hills north-west of Barcelona, the car crept down scary inclines, forded rivers, and picked its way over alarming-looking rock formations. No one could doubt the supreme capability of the vehicle. Cynics might wonder just how often this capability, gained with some very expensive, and heavy, technology would be required.

Not just a mud-plugger
But the Range Rover isn’t just for playing in the mud. In the real road world the vehicle performs very well. The cabin is top class. The driving position is high and commanding. The seats are luxurious and cosseting. The dash board and controls fit conveniently around the driver. The quality of the materials, with wood, leather and metal trim are to the manor born.

Land Rover says the new diesel exceeds European Union Euro 4 emission standards, but this won’t herald an onslaught on the U.S. market, where diesel power is set to take-off. Disappointingly, the new engine won’t meet the extremely tough clean air standards in the U.S.

Mercedes Benz is about to make a big impression in America when it starts to sell its BlueTec diesel powered E class cars next month. The Bluetec system undercuts Euro 4 standards for smog producing nitrogen oxides (NOx) by more than 70 per cent. The U.S. has extremely stringent NOx limits, and is about to introduce much tougher sulphur content rules for diesel fuel – to 15 parts per million from 500 ppm. This is the first step on the road to the acceptance of diesel power in America.

J.D.Power has said that by 2012 almost twice as many diesels as hybrid cars will be sold in America – 4.2 per cent hybrid market share versus 7.6 per cent diesel. In 2004, hybrids powered about 0.5 per cent of cars, with 3 per cent diesel. Mercedes reckons that diesel market share in the U.S. will increase fourfold from the current 3.4 per cent over the next 10 years.

Diesels will be a must in America too
Land Rover won’t say when it will be ready to assault the U.S. with diesels, but you can be sure that if it is to retain its position in the biggest market in the world, futuristic diesels will have to be on its agenda.

Meanwhile, reading that article from Clarkson again it really does seem that he loves regular Range Rovers as much as I do. He just hated the jazzed up, tacky Overfinch. Now that is worrying.

Neil Winton – September 20, 2006

Range Rover TDV8 HSE
3.6 litre diesel
272 bhp
6-speed automatic
all wheels
0-60 mph 8.5 seconds 0-100 km/h 9.2
Top Speed:
124 mph/200 km/h
Fuel Consumption:
claimed combined – 25.1 mpg-11.3 l/km
CO2 Emissions:
not available
4,972 mm
Weight: 2,710 kg
Toyota Land Cruiser Amazon, Mercedes GL, BMW X5, Audi Q7, Jeep Commander, Porsche Cayenne, Nissan Patrol
Same for Less: Hyundai Santa Fe
Would I buy one?
***** out of 5
Insurance Group: 16E
magnificent cruiser, cossets you in luxury as you ooze down the highway, or across raging rivers or dangerous deserts carrying all your worldly goods.
pricey; provokes greens, underclass despite diesel economy

home page / more reviews / auto industry news / top of page